Critical Response Essay - 893 Words

Critical Response Essay The real debate - the pipe-dream or nuclear? Mark Kenny The Nation Mark Kennys article on the coal power versus nuclear power debate was published in the Advertiser on the 31st of October 2009. The Advertiser is South Australias only daily tabloid newspaper, and is widely distributed around South Australia allowing for a large dispersion of readers from diverse cultural backgrounds and an assortment of age groups. The article has Mark Kennys photograph situated next to a quote from the conclusion of his article stating â€Å"Its time for a real debate which admits clean coal is a pipe-dream and safe nuclear is a global reality†. It also has a cartoon of Peter Garrett being portrayed as lead singer of†¦show more content†¦The qualifier indicates the strength from the data used in the grounds to the warrant, and may be the defining factor in how strong the claim of the argument is. Finally the rebuttal is used to limit the effectiveness of counter-arguments and prevent this affecting the persuasion of views being expressed, Kenny rarel y uses this element of the argument and if so only very slightly at the end of the article â€Å"Mr Garrett claimed there was a vigorous debate at the last election that had settled the matter clearly† on nuclear power, however Kenny immediately claims this to be false. Overall Mark Kennys article The real debate – pipe-dream or nuclear presents a persuasive argument however not without flaws. Kenny has gone for a hard hitting article to strongly express his viewpoints and through that has made it to one sided and opinionated which has led to elements of false analogies in his argument along with generalisations. He also verges on quoting out of context when referring to Peter Garrett and makes isolated individual examples through evidence that affects his line of reasoning and the readers validity of his argument due to lack of looking at both sides of the issue in relation to coal-fuelled and nuclear power. Word Count: 878 References Kenny, M. 31st October 2009. The real debate – pipe-dream dream or nuclear. The Advertiser. Johnson, S. 12th April 2010. Coal-fuelled future for Australia. The West Australian. Streaker, D.Show MoreRelated The Soldier - Critical Response Essay856 Words   |  4 Pages A poem which I have read recently is â€Å"Soldier† by Rupert Brooke. The main point in question throughout this poem is appreciation for ones country. I will prove that this is the main point in question during the course of my essay. The poem â€Å"Soldier† is Brooke’s views on the possible occurrence of his own death in the field and what he feels that foreign country would gain from his death. When viewing his own death Brooke only looks at the thoughts and ways England has provided him with in the courseRead MoreEssay on Critical Response to the Grapes of Wrath616 Words   |  3 PagesJohn Steinbeck went into writing about the Dust Bowl migration feeling that he had the responsibility to convey the problem correctly. The Grapes of Wrath not only works as a call to action in favor of the masses of migrant workers that were forced to live in poverty, but also expresses several other messages about mankind itself. Steinbeck uses powerful imagery, unique and suspenseful structure, dramatic tone, and compelling symbolism to effectively squeeze a mountain of an issue into pages of textRead MoreCritical Response of Duff and Pugh Essay1358 Words   |  6 PagesCritical Response Carol Ann-Duffy Sheenagh Pugh are both strongly opinionated politically – many of their poems are charged with a scornful, impassioned energy directed toward the Thatcherite days, resenting years of economic deprivation ruin of many young lives in their generation – this sets the basis for a general distaste for politicians, illustrated in Duffy’s parody of parliament ‘Weasel Words’, mocking the meaningless socio-jargon that MPs use to wriggle and slither their way out ofRead MoreEssay on A Critical Response to Vitruvius Alberti1034 Words   |  5 PagesARC131 H1F 3rd October 2012 Mikaile Ibrahim FIRMITAS, UTILITAS, VENUSTAS A CRITICAL RESPONSE TO VITRUVIUS amp; ALBERTI Throughout history, the makings of an architect have changed by stark proportions and so did the requirements of the finished creation. Marcus Vitruvius Pollio (80 B.C.E), famously known as Vitruvius, wrote in The Ten Books on Architecture of how the architect must possess wide knowledge and expertise in many fields of study, and that his buildings must encompass firmitasRead MoreEssay about Critical Response to the Turn of the Screw851 Words   |  4 PagesHenry James’ novella the Turn of the Screw is a highly ambiguous piece of fiction. Set in Edwardian England, a very naà ¯ve woman is left in charge of two young children. The beautiful Bly however appears to be hiding a few dark secrets. The appearance of two ghosts plays on the governess’ mind, she comes to the conclusion the children are in danger and being possessed by these two horrors. Throughout the novella James successfully creates a mystical atmosphere, his ambiguous style forces us to thinkRead MoreCriti cal Response Essay Final - I Have a Dream981 Words   |  4 Pages‘I have a Dream’ – Critical Response Essay ------------------------------------------------- How does ‘I have a Dream’ By Martin Luther King conform to, or deviate from, the conventions of a persuasive speech, and for what purpose? ------------------------------------------------- I have chosen the question â€Å"How does the text conform to, or deviate from, the conventions of a particular genre, and for what purpose?† I have decided to analyse Martin Luther King’s classic Civil Rights MovementRead MoreDulce Et Decorum Est - Critical Response Essay1159 Words   |  5 PagesA poem which I have recently read is: Dulce Et Decorum Est by Wilfred Owen. The main point Wilfred Owen tries to convey in this poem is the sheer horror of war. Owen uses many techniques to show his feelings, some of which Ill be exploring. br brWilfred Owen is a tired soldier on the front line during World War I. In the first stanza of Dulce Et Decorum Est he describes the men and the condition they are in and through his language shows that the soldiers deplore the conditions. Owen thenRead MoreEssay about A Critical Response to Lady Chatterleys Lover1886 Words   |  8 PagesA Critical Response to Lady Chatterleys Lover      Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚   Lady Chatterleys Lover by D. H. Lawrence examines the human condition in the modern era.   Through the experiences of the novels characters, Lady Chatterleys Lover advances techniques for coping with the modern world:   retreating from society and engaging in phallic sex.   However, the application of these techniques is problematic as phallic sex necessitates the abandonment of social convention, while retreating from society conflictsRead More Dulce Et Decorum Est - Critical Response Essay1129 Words   |  5 Pages A poem which I have recently read is: â€Å"Dulce Et Decorum Est† by Wilfred Owen. The main point Wilfred Owen tries to convey in this poem is the sheer horror of war. Owen uses many techniques to show his feelings, some of which I’ll be exploring. Wilfred Owen is a tired soldier on the front line during World War I. In the first stanza of Dulce Et Decorum Est he describes the men and the condition they are in and through his language shows that the soldiers deplore the conditions. Owen then moves onRead MoreMy Writing Is Easy Isn t Doing It Right985 Words   |  4 Pagesimportantly, critical thinking. The first graded assignment of the course was a profile essay. The objective was to gather information, using the techniques of field research and to gain experience with narration, description, and examples; as described in our assignment rubric. We were to draw on memory, observation, or interviews to write about a person who represents something larger than him/herself or about one aspect of a person. I was especially intimidated to begin this essay. I had no idea